Paris, Capital of Modernity

Paris, Capital of Modernity

By: David Harvey  

Buy it now at Amazon.com!

Average Customer Rating: 4.0 out of 5

Publisher: Routledge

Customer Review: 2 out of 5
Bad read, not cohesive - In writing this book, David Harvey did not use original documents to gather his facts and analyses. Instead, he read countless secondary works. If you have read many of these books that Harvey used, maybe you'd find this book interesting. If you have some knowledge of French history and want to enhance it, then look elsewhere.

There are many problems with this book. The three parts do not go together. They should not be in one book. Part 1 is primarily about Parisian writers (Balzac in particular) and other artists from 1830-48. It's a waste of a few dozen pages. Completely pointless. The last part is more readable, but it pertains to the Commune and the building of a religious structure, not with how Paris became the capital of modernity.

Part 2 is the one that pertains to the topic of the book, but it's extremely dense. You don't learn much from the book, other than Harvey's views. He's entirely too wordy and he's in love with disrupting your reading flow with useless items in parentheses right in the middle of sentences. I found myself getting angry with his reader-unfriendly style.

The bottom line is, this book will not educate you on the Second Empire. If you already have a boatload of knowledge about the period and you enjoy reading the views of a self-indulgent geographer, knock yourself out. Personally I hope to never see the book again.

Customer Review: 5 out of 5
A cultural and geographical history of Second Empire Paris - David Harvey, the famous social geographer, is not particularly known for his work on cultural matters, having spent most of his career working on issues of political economy, spatial organization and (some) philosophy of the same. Nonetheless, "Paris, Capital of Modernity" is a partially cultural, partially political-geographical history of the modernization of Paris undertaken under the famous leadership of Georges Haussmann (1809-1891), who created the monument, park and boulevard systems for which Paris is now justly renowned. As context, Harvey analyzes the works and attitudes of famous writers of that period in Paris, such as Flaubert and De Balzac, in addition to providing many nice photographs and maps charting the changes and developments in France's capital.

As one can expect with Harvey, most of the work is spent on tracing the geographical and spatial aspects of the modernization and industrialization of Paris and its political background in the persons of Napoleon III, Emperor of France between 1852 and 1870, and Georges Haussmann. He shows the constellation of class forces that allowed Napoleon III to play various classes against each other, shifting support from financial capital to landlord powers and back, and the position Haussmann's developments had in this political ensemble. Although the initial material is a little dry, things get better as Harvey digs into the meat of the matter, where Haussmann does not appear as much as the hated enemy of the workers and wrecker of ancient Paris as he is often depicted, but rather as an embodiment of the 'creative destruction' that capitalism is when it fully comes into its own, as it did in France around this time. The tensions and furies caused by the combination of capitalist industrialization on the one hand, and the spatial and economic restructuring of Paris as such by Haussmann and speculators both would finally erupt into the Paris Commune of 1871, which inaugurated the permanent end of the power of both reaction and a bloody repression of socialism in France.

The book is written with the usual subtlety, political understanding, and nuance of Harvey's best work. Whether the literary additions to the work are an improvement or a distraction perhaps depends on taste, all the more since the first chapter, entirely on De Balzac's oeuvre, is rather at variance with the topic of the rest of the work. But although the topic of Paris' furious ascent into modernity is not quite a new topic (addressed famously by Walter Benjamin, for example), Harvey's book is a worthy addition to Marx' own studies on the history of France: "The Eighteenth Brumaire of Napoleon Bonaparte" (The Eighteenth Brumaire of Louis Bonaparte) and "The Civil War in France" (The Civil War in France: The Paris Commune).

Customer Review: 5 out of 5
Paris as archetype - Implicitly taking his start from Benjamin's sketches of Paris as the "capitol" of the 19th century, Harvey analyses the elements that transformed Paris from medieval labrynth to modern bourgeois metropolis and the corresponding effect that this had on all levels of the class structure, men and women, and the spatial geography of the city itself. He starts with Balzac and Baudelaire, as all such studies must; but quickly moves out of literature and into history, looking at the changes in the city geography begun by Hausmann. Harvey uses his familiar metaphor of changes in geography as a symbol of the changes wrought by modernity. Excellent, pointed read for those interested in Paris and French history, urban development, and the effects of capital on capitols. Great bibliography too!

--> Find out more about "Paris, Capital of Modernity" at Amazon.com or Order Now